Skip to Main Content
Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar logo topJay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar logo scroll
  • (614)-626-0300
  • 10705 Blacklick-Eastern Road Northwest , Pickerington
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • ORDER
  • Facebook pageYelp page
Jay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar logo topJay's Crab Boil & Oyster Bar logo scroll
  • Facebook pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • ORDER

Our Menu

Menu

* Items are served raw or uncooked. Consuming raw or undercooked meals may increase the risk of foodborne illness | Notice - before placiing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy, especially to shellfish or raw food | No Exchanges or returns! All sales final - once an order placed with a server it cannot be modified/canceled | 38% Gratuity will be added to parties of 5 or more

Seafood Boil Lunch Special

Monday - Sunday: 12:00 pm - 4:00 pm (Lunch Only) | Each combo is served in one bag, one seasoning, and one spice level. No substitutions. Includes: potatoes, egg, sausages, and corn. Shrimp (head off) $2.00 extra

LUNCH COMBO A

$18.00
Pick any two 1/2 lb: Shrimp (head-on), Clam, Manila Clam, Mussels, Crawfish

LUNCH COMBO B

$25.95
Pick two 1 lb.: Shrimp (head-on), Clam, Manila Clam, Mussels, Crawfish
LUNCH COMBO C photo

LUNCH COMBO C

$35.00
One 7 oz - 8 oz snow crab cluster with two 1/2 lb of the following: Shrimp (head-on), Clam, Manila Clam, Mussels, Crawfish

Sauce Option:

Jay's Southern Cajun Sauce (no butter) | Original Cajun | Garlic Butter | Dry (Old Bay Only) | Lemon Pepper | Garlic and Butter Only | The Jay's Special Blend

Level Option:

Mild | Medium | Spicy | Extra Spicy | Fire

Signature Item

Special Grilled Shrimp

$18.95
Lobster Mac and Cheese photo

Lobster Mac and Cheese

$15.95
Real lobster meat wit mac and cheese | With Jay's special seasoning and cheese load french fries
Jay's Super Wagyu Burger photo

Jay's Super Wagyu Burger

$18.00
5 Buns 1/2 lb wogyu burger loaded pico & queso fries | Special $15.95

Tequila Lime Cheesy Chicken Finger

$15.95
Oven grilled chicken finger with tequila lime sauce and cheese, rosated red potato, red onion and bell pepper | Special: $15.95

Char-Grilled Cheesy Chicken Finger

$15.95
Oven grilled chicken finger with classic char-grill sauce and cheese, roasted red potato, red onion and bell pepper | Special $15.95
Special Surf and Turf photo

Special Surf and Turf

$44.95/+
8oz filet mignom with oven baked 6oz lobster tail. Top with spicy micro green finished with beurre blanc | With choice of two sides: broccoli, mashed potato, asparagus and red potato | Special: $44.95 | Regular: $49.95
Lobster with Beurre Blanc photo

Lobster with Beurre Blanc

$34.95/+
Warm water spiny lobster with beurre blanc sauce | With choice of two sides: broccoli, mashed potato, asparagus and red potato | Special: $34.95 | Regular: $36.95
Cheesy Char-Grilled Lobster photo

Cheesy Char-Grilled Lobster

$34.95/+
Warm water spiny lobster with char-grill sauce and cheese | With choice of two sides: broccoli, mashed potato, asparagus and red potato | Special: $34.95 | Regular: $37.95
Special Duck Breast with Cheery Red Wine Sauce photo

Special Duck Breast with Cheery Red Wine Sauce

$21.95
7oz grilled duck breast | With choice of two sides: broccoli, mashed potato, asparagus and red potato | Special: $21.95
French dip prime rib sandwich photo

French dip prime rib sandwich

$18.00
- Limited Supply - French dip slow-roasted prime rib sandwich. - Come with house soup or salad and choice of one side: fried red potatoes, French fries, sweet potato waffle, fried cajun fries. - With Au Jus sauce and sour cream horseradish sauce.
Jay’s Special Roast Prime rib (USDA choice) photo

Jay’s Special Roast Prime rib (USDA choice)

$22.99/10oz
$24.99/12oz
$28.99/16oz
- With house salad or soup and choice of one side: broccoli, mashed potato, asparagus, and red potato.

Char-grilled chilean sea bass

$27.99
- 8 oz Chilean Sea Bass - With Asparagus & Red Potatoes - With Jays Special Blend Louisiana Style Sauce or Cajun Blackened Seasoning
Jay's Special Surf 'n' Turf photo

Jay's Special Surf 'n' Turf

$27.95
- 8 oz Ribeye and 10 grilled Cajun-style Shrimp. - With Asparagus and Garlic Bread.

jay's fried seafood platter

$19.95
2 Crab Cake, 2 oz Clams, 2 Catfish, 6 Calamari and 4 Shrimp.

Char-Grilled

Char-Grilled Lobster and Argentina Red Shrimp

$34.95
6oz warm water lobster tail, 4 pieces jumbo argentina red shrimp wild caught | With asparagus & red potatoes | With Jay's special blend Louisiana style sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | Special: $34.95

Char-Grilled Salmon & Shrimp

$26.95/+
The wester ross selection sashimi grade, 8oz | 4 pieces jumbo argentina red shrimp wild caught | With asparagus & red potatoes | With Jay's special blend Louisiana style sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | Special: $26.95 | Regular: $32.95

Char-Grilled Blackened Walleye

$21.95
With asparagus & red potatoes | With Jay's special blend Louisiana style sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | Special: $21.95

Char-Grilled Blackened Catfish

$19.95
With asparagus & red potatoes | With Jay's special blend Louisiana style sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | Special: $19.95

Lava Stone Grill

Cook yourself on 600 degrees stone or you can ask servers if you prefer kitchen cook for you

Jay's Special Lamb

$27.99
3 pieces lamb | With salad, fried red potato | With Jay's special choice sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | Special: $27.99

Jay's Special Ribeye

$32.95
10oz USDA choice grade Ohio farm raised | With salad, fried red potato, with Jay's special choice sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | Special: $32.95

Jay's Special Lobster & Shrimp

$34.95
6oz warm water lobster tail, 4 pieces jumbo argentina red shrimp wild caught | With salad, fried red potato, with Jay's special choice sauce or cajun blackened seasoning

Jay's Special Salmon & Shrimp

$24.95
With salad, fried red potato | With Jay's special choice sauce or cajun blackened seasoning | The Wester Ross selection sashimi grade 8oz | 4 pieces jumbo argentina red shrimp wild caught | Special: $24.95

Pick Your Catch

Include: Potato, corn, sausage and egg | Add an extra side of dipping sauce +$3.25. No substitution | Double Seasoning +$0.75

STEP 1: PICK YOUR CATCH

Manila Clam

$9.25/1/2 lb
$14.00/1 lb

Clam

$9.25/1/2 lb
$14.00/1 lb

Crawfish

$10.25/1/2 lb
$14.00/1 lb

Black Mussel

$10.00/1/2 lb
$16.00/1 lb

New Zealand Mussel

$10.00/1/2 lb
$16.00/1 lb

Shrimp (Head-on)

$12.00/1/2 lb
$19.00/1 lb

Shrimp (Head-off)

$12.25/1/2 lb
$20.00/1 lb

Lobster Tail (6oz Tail)

MP
MP

Snow Crab Leg

MP
MP

Dungeness Crab

MP
MP

King Crab Leg

MP
MP

Blue Crab (Seasonal)

MP
MP

LIVE SEAFOOD SEASONAL SUPPLY:

Live Lobster

MP

Live Dungeness Crab

MP
MP

Live King Crab

MP
MP

STEP 2: PICK YOUR SAUCE

Original Cajun

Garlic Butter

Dry (Old Bay Only)

Lemon Pepper

Garlic and Butter Only

The Jay's Special Blend

Jay's Southern Cajun Southern Sauce

(No Butter)

STEP 3: PICK 1 LEVEL

Mild

Medium

Spicy

Extra Spicy

Fire

EXTRAS

Corn On The Cob (3 pcs)

$2.50

Potatoes (3 pcs)

$2.50

Sausage (1/2 lb)

$5.75

Boiled Eggs (2 pcs)

$2.50

Combos Deal

Each combo is served in one bag, one seasoning, and one spice level. No substitutions. Includes: 2 potatoes, 1 egg, 4 sausages, and 2 corn. Shrimp (head off) $2.00 extra

COM #1

$26.00
Pick any three: Shrimp, Clams, Crawfish, or Mussels - 1/2 lb

COM #2

$34.50
1/2 lb Snow Crab Leg, 1/2 lb Shrimp, and 1/2 lb Sausage

COM #3

$37.00
One 7oz - 8oz snow crab cluster with two 1/2 lb of the following: Shrimp (Head-on), Clam, Manila Clam, Mussels, Crawfish

COM #4

$49.00
A) Your choice: 6oz Lobster Tail or 1 lb Snow Crab Leg | B) Your choice: pick one Shrimp, Clams, Crawfish, or Mussels - 1 lb

COM #5

$59.00
A) Your choice: 6oz Lobster Tail or 1 lb Snow Crab Legs | B) Your choice: pick two Shrimp, Clams, Crawfish, or Mussels - 1 lb

Family Plate Combos Deal - #A

$149.00
Include 8 eggs, 8 potatoes, 8 corn and 1.5 lb sausage | 1.5 Snow Crab | 1 Piece 6oz Lobster Tail | 1.5 lb Shrimp | 1.5 lb Mussel | 1.5 Crawfish

Family Plate Combos Deal - #B

$264.00
Include 8 eggs, 8 potatoes, 8 corn and 1.5 lb sausage | 3 Snow Crab | 2 Piece 6oz Lobster Tail | 2 lb Shrimp | 2 lb Mussel | 3 lb Crawfish

Oyster

Ask servers for our oyster selection today

Stuffed Clams(4)

$12.95

Chargrilled Rockefeller Oyster (6)

$19.95

Rockefeller Oyster (6)

$18.95
Fresh open baked

Char-Grilled Oysters (6)

$18.95
Fresh open baked

Kumamoto Oyster

$3.75
Oakland, WA | Flavor: Mild brine with creamy meats and a honeydew finish

Pink Lady Oyster

$3.25
New London, PEI | Flavor: A perfect balance of salt, creaminess and a pleasant mineral finish

Oyster Shooters

$6.50
Vodka, Bloody Mary mix, Horse Radish, Worceserchire, lemon squeeze, salt, hot sauce to desire heat

Raspberry Point Oyster

$3.25
New London, PEI | Flavor: Springy meat with a gentle brine and sweet mushroom finish

Blue Point Oyster

$3.00
Westport & Norwalk Islands, CT | Flavor: Medium salinity, springy meat and a light mineral finish

Cold Bar

With cocktail sauce, horseradish sauce, soy sauce, wasabi, and lemon.

Old Bay Cocktail Shrimp (10)

$13.95

Half Dozen Live Calms

$12.95

Cocktail Shrimp (10)

$13.95

One Dozen Restaurant Select Variety Livestock Oysters

$31.00

Half Dozen Restaurant Select Variety Livestock Oysters

$16.00

CREATE YOUR OWN TOWER SEAFOOD TOWER:

4 Oyster

$10.00

6 Cocktail Shrimp

$7.00

6 Mussels

$13.00

4 Clams

$8.00

1/2 lb Snow Crab Legs

MP
MP

1/2 lb King Crab Legs

MP
MP

6oz Lobster Tail

MP
MP

Appetizers

Served with choice of sauce: Ketchup, cocktail, tartar, spicy mayo, horseradish, or marinara sauce. No substitutions.

Beef Pizza

$14.95

Surf Turf Pizza

$14.95

Seafood Lobster Pizza

$14.95
Jay's Special Chicken Nachos photo

Jay's Special Chicken Nachos

$8.95
Jay's Special Steak Nachos photo

Jay's Special Steak Nachos

$9.95
Jay's Special Lobster Nachos photo

Jay's Special Lobster Nachos

$11.95

Char-Grilled Rockefeller Oyster (6)

$19.95

Rockefeller Oyster (6)

$18.95
Char-Grilled Oyster (6) photo

Char-Grilled Oyster (6)

$18.95

Stuffed Clam

$12.95

Buffalo Beef Eggrolls (3)

$8.75
Beef Bone Marrow photo

Beef Bone Marrow

$13.95

White Wine Mussle

$12.95
Hush Puppies (10) photo

Hush Puppies (10)

$5.00

Seafood Fried Rice

$9.00
Fried Mozzarella Cheese (6) photo

Fried Mozzarella Cheese (6)

$6.00

Wings (breaded or plain)

$7.00
Choice of: BBQ, Buffalo, Cajun, or Lemon Pepper
Fried Calamari photo

Fried Calamari

$9.25
Chicken Tenders (3) photo

Chicken Tenders (3)

$7.75

Garlic Bread (4)

$4.99
Crab Stuffed Tots (8) photo

Crab Stuffed Tots (8)

$10.00
Jay's Special Fried Sampler photo

Jay's Special Fried Sampler

$13.95

Loaded Fries

$6.50

Salad / Soup

Salad dressing: Blue cheese, ranch, house dressing

Jay's Seafood Chowder Soup

$4.95

Caesar Salad

$5.99

Lobster Louie Salad

$12.99

Jay's Seafood Louie Salad

$9.99

Crab Louie Salad

$9.99

Lobster Bisque

$6.95

Basket

Served with choice of sauce, ketchup, cosktail, tartar, spicy mayo, horseradish or marinara sauce. Each basket comes with french fries, sweet potato fries or cajun fries | Substitute fries with soup or salad for $2.50 extra

Buffalo Shrimp Basket

$12.75

Coconut Shrimp Basket

$14.25

Chicken Tenders Basket

$9.95
Fried Shrimp Basket photo

Fried Shrimp Basket

$13.75

Fried Oyster Basket

$14.95
Fried Catfish Basket photo

Fried Catfish Basket

$13.75

Fried Tilapia Basket

$12.75

Wings Basket (Breaded or Plain)

$14.00
Choice of: BBQ, Buffalo, Cajun, and Lemon Pepper

Fried Walleye

$18.75

Fried Yellow Perch

$18.95

Fried Clams Basket

$12.75

Sliders / Rolls

All come with french fries, sweet potato fries or cajun fries | Substitute fries with soup or salad for $2.50 extra

Shrimp Roll

$12.99
4oz meat, hot or cold, per 2oz extra, upcharge $3.95

Lobster Roll

$22.95
4oz meat, hot or cold, per 2oz extra, upcharge $10.00

Shrimp and Lobster Roll

$17.95
2oz lobster, 2oz shrimp

Jay's Philly Steak Roll

$12.99

Jay's Philly Chicken Roll

$11.49

Fish Sliders (3)

$13.75

Chicken Burger Sliders (3)

$12.25

Crabmeat Slider

$15.75

Po Boy Sandwiches

All come with french fries, sweet potato fries or cajun fries | Substitute fries with soup or salad for $2.50 extra

Chicken Po Boy

$11.25

Fried Fish Po Boy

$13.75

Shrimp Po Boy

$14.00

Oyster Po Boy

$14.25

Pasta

Add soup or salad for $3.99 extra

Chicken Linguine

$11.99

Steak Lingiuine

$12.99

Seafood Linguine

$12.99

Sides

Fried Red Potato

$3.00

Broccoli

$3.00

Asparagus

$3.00

White Rice

$2.50

Linguine

$2.50

Mashed Potato

$2.50

Fries

$3.00

Cajun Fries

$3.50

Sweet Potato Fries

$3.50

Fried Shrimp (6)

$6.99

Coconut Shrimp (6)

$6.99

Grilled Shrimp (6)

$6.99

Dessert

Ice Cream

$2.95

Cheese Cake

$5.00

Chocolate Cake

$6.50

Kids Sundae

$2.50
  • Order
  • Parties